- W
- D
- W
- W
Colorado Rapids - Houston Dynamo
New York Red Bulls - Houston Dynamo
New York City FC - Houston Dynamo
Houston Dynamo - New England Revolution
- L
- W
- W
- D
Colorado Rapids - Houston Dynamo
New York City FC - Colorado Rapids
New England Revolution - Colorado Rapids
Sporting Kansas City - Colorado Rapids
- W
- W
- L
- L
New England Revolution - New York Red Bulls
New England Revolution - Sporting Kansas City
New England Revolution - Colorado Rapids
Houston Dynamo - New England Revolution
- L
- L
- W
- D
New York City FC - Sporting Kansas City
New England Revolution - Sporting Kansas City
New York Red Bulls - Sporting Kansas City
Sporting Kansas City - Colorado Rapids
- L
- D
- L
- W
New England Revolution - New York Red Bulls
New York Red Bulls - Houston Dynamo
New York Red Bulls - Sporting Kansas City
New York City FC - New York Red Bulls
- W
- L
- L
- L
New York City FC - Sporting Kansas City
New York City FC - Colorado Rapids
New York City FC - Houston Dynamo
New York City FC - New York Red Bulls